The Great Pie Adventure

Pie. Across Eugene there has to be an array of it; vegan, local, mushy, buttery, unconventional, Crisco-y, from a Sysco truck, from the farm down the road–this is The Great Pie Adventure and it will go as far as my measly graduate student budget will allow. Bottoms up kids, we’re going in!

Reviewed so far:

Blackberry pie, Beckie’s Cafe.

Beckie’s Cafe–The pie at Beckie’s is divine. It is something you must try. Unlike the rest of the pies listed here, Beckie’s is located in the Rogue River Forest near Crater Lake. It’s worth stopping by if you’re out that way exploring though. Each day you can pick from about 13 different types of pie at this wonderful little cafe, where most everything is made from scratch. The crust is thin, buttery-looking and stuffed full of fruit (or chocolate cream, etc.). What’s most distinct about the fruit pies is that the filling is thick, it doesn’t run all over the plate. You can also top your pie with ice cream and sip it over a cup of coffee. Full review here.

Beckie’s| 56484 Oregon 62 Prospect, OR 97536|(541) 560-3563|Winter hours:  Sun.-Thur. 8 a.m.-7 p.m., Fri.-Sat. 8 a.m.-8 p.m.|Cost for a piece of pie with ice cream $3-$4|Whole pie $16-$18 (handmade in-house by a baker)

Overall rating: 5 out of 5

College student friendly? YES.| Food 5 out of 5| Prices: 5 out of 5| Environment: 5 out of 5.

Marionberry, Sour Cream Lemon, and Apple pies from Metropol.

Metropol BakeryIt is very obvious that the bakers at Metropol put a lot of love and care into each pie. Metropol does a great job with the classics, and an excellent job with the sour cream lemon pie, a pie that you aren’t going to find very many other places. The crusts are all wonderfully crafted: flaky and buttery. The apple crumble is very dense, the marionberry tastes fresh and the sour cream lemon pie is light, creamy like pudding, sweet and lemony. Full review here.

Metropol|2538 Willamette Street, Eugene, OR 97405| (541) 465-4730| Hours: M-F 7 a.m.-7 p.m., Sat.-Sun. 7 a.m.-8 p.m.| Cost for a piece of pie: around $4

Overall rating: 5 out of 5

College student friendly? Yes.| Food 5 out of 5| Prices: 4.5 out of 5| Environment: 5 out of 5 (They currently have a tribute to Brian Lanker, a Eugene photographer up) AND they have coffee.

Apple-raspberry, a nice combination at Mom’s Pies.

Mom’s PiesThis downtown pie haven will bring you back to grandma’s kitchen in rural Oregon, where the decorations are sparse but the cookin’ is darn good. At any given time several varieties of pie are available by the slice.  The slices, which vary from peach to strawberry rhubarb are freshly baked each day. Sometimes, later in the afternoon the selection dwindles down to apple-raspberry and apple, a last-pick that won’t leave you unsatisfied or sad. Coffee? Check. Ice cream? Check. Affordable? Yes indeed. Ignoring the atmosphere, this is the perfect place to satisfy your pie craving on a college budget. Then again, we’ve been known to have some of the best memories in the oddest places, Burrito Boy anyone?  Full review here.

Mom’s Pies |1133 Willamette Street, Eugene, OR 97401| (541) 484-6667| Hours: Mon.-Sat. 10 a.m.-5 p.m.| Cost for a piece of pie: $2.99

College student friendly? Yes.| Food 4.5 out of 5| Prices: 5 out of 5| Environment: 3 out of 5 (It’s not bad, just a little awkward. Some music and more tables would help)

Mixed Berry Pie from Sweet Life.

Sweet Life–Mixed berry pie. As a whole, the pie works well together. It is fresh, it is local and it’s filling. The raspberries are present, the blackberries an undertone and the strawberries a mummer. Meanwhile whole blueberries are present in just about every bite. The crust is golden and lightly covered with sugar. Where it comes together it is just a touch too dry. Full review here.

Sweet Life Patisserie|755 Monroe Street, Eugene, OR 97402-5135|(541) 683-5676|Hours:  Mon.-Fri. 7a.m.-11p.m., Saturday-Sunday 8a.m.-11p.m.|Cost for a piece of mixed berry pie $4-$5

Overall rating: 4.5 out of 5

College student friendly? Yes.| Food 4.5 out of 5| Prices: 4 out of 5| Environment: 5 out of 5 AND they have coffee.


20 responses to “The Great Pie Adventure

  1. Pingback: The Great Pie Adventure Part II « Two Pots of Coffee and A Slice of Pie at Midnight·

    • Homemade is always better! No debate there. Nevermind, one exception: Becky’s in Union Creek, Oregon. We’re talking a diner in the middle of the Forrest. They use fresh picked berries from you know, like 2 feet from the diner and then put together the best pie I’ve ever had. When I was little camping wasn’t complete without a slice of Becky’s blackberry pie. As for your cake idea, I picked pie because it was my very favorite dessert ever. The problem with cake is there are few places that think outside the box, and there are so many other neglected desserts! Perhaps after I’m done exploring pie in Eugene I’ll try cake. There’s no reason cake can’t pop in for a short appearance in other reviews though, so I’ll keep my eye out 😀

  2. Is that the same “Mom’s Pies” that used to be up the McKenzie? Fyi, I was at a brewey on Olympic Penin. last weekend and my date asked what desserts they had. Server said “choc. , apple, cherry,and banana bread pudding”, but all I heard was no pie…so we skipped dessert.

  3. Is critiquing a review, even legal? Isn’t that against the constitution? Free speech and all that? My love of Cornucopia overrides my ethical writer sense. Here goes my delicious rendering of The Great Pie Adventure.
    My first criticism – you didn’t invite me. My pies have won blue ribbons at the County Fair, so I have some expertise in this field. Secondly, did you mean to say mummer or a murmur? And my last criticism is the use of dense with the apple crumb. It seems unclear as to what this refers to exactly – the crumbs, the apples, the opacity? Yes, I would like more clarification as to the particular density of this pie.

    • Eularee Smith, you are wonderful. Thank you so much, I think that is super helpful. I’m still working on my pie adventure, we just went to New Day. Would you like to come along to the next place? I’d love to have you. Shall I add you to the giveaway list as well?

  4. Hi Melissa,
    I love the marionberry pies at Beackies Cafe! The unfortunate thing is that they run out quickly. I have a B&B in Ashland, Oregon and I often send my guests to this wonderful stop over on their way up to Crater Lake and they always come home raving about the pie almost as much as Crater Lake. That’s say’n something!
    Love your posts. Thanks for sharing!
    BayberryInn B&B
    Ashland, Oregon

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s